Recently, the regulatory framework of administrative liability of entities for criminal offences has been partially amended, by (i) recognizing its central role within the framework of public tenders’ regulations, and (ii) expanding the catalogue of predicate offences (reati presupposto or 231 crimes).

• 231 Corporate Liability as Ground for Exclusion from Public Tenders

Legislative Decree no. 36/2023, i.e., the new Italian Public Tenders Code (“PTC”), distinguishes between causes of automatic exclusion (Section 94) and causes of non-automatic exclusion from public tenders (Section 95).

In case of:

• a criminal conviction or disqualification measure for the criminal offences listed under Section 94, paragraphs 1 and 2, of the PTC issued against an economic operator under Legislative Decree No. 231/2001 (Section 94, paragraphs 3, lett. a) and 5), or
• a disqualification sanction referred to in Section 9, paragraph 2, lett. c) of Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 (or of any other sanction entailing the prohibition to enter into agreements with public entities)

the sanctioned entity will be automatically excluded from the public tender.

Moreover, if a 231 crime is ascertained, or even only contested, then a “serious professional offence” is triggered, which may lead to a non-automatic cause of exclusion from the public tender (Section 98 of the PTC).

• New 231 Crimes

Following the PTC, Law no. 137/2023 increases the number of 231 crimes by providing for the inclusion of the following criminal offences:

• Obstruction of tender procedures (in Italian, “Turbata libertà degli incanti”, Section 353 of the Italian criminal code), i.e., hindering or disrupting a public tender or turning away bidders by violence, threats, gifts, promises, collusion or other fraudulent means;
• Obstruction of the choice of contractor procedure (in Italian, “Turbata libertà del procedimento di scelta del contraente”, Section 353-bis of the Italian criminal code), i.e., disruption of the administrative procedure by way of violence or threats, or by gifts, promises, collusion or other fraudulent means, in order to influence the manner in which the public administration chooses a contractor; and
• Fraudulent transfer of values (in Italian, “Trasferimento fraudolento di valori”, Section 512-bis of the Italian Criminal code), i.e., fictitious attribution of the ownership or availability of money, goods or other utilities for the purpose of avoid the application of the provisions of the regulation on asset prevention measures or smuggling, or of facilitating the commission of one of the offences referred to in Sections 648, 648-bis and 648-ter.

The novelties described above shows the Italian legislator’s increasing attention to the conduct of entities participating in public tenders, and will result in the need to review and update the 231 model already adopted by entities, in order to (i) provide for procedures to ensure correctness of the company’s conduct with specific regard to participation in public tenders, and (ii) take into account the three new 231 crimes.